top of page

Our Obsession with Futurism at the Cost of Discipline Will Be Our Downfall

7 days ago
5 min read

An exploration of whether our collective maturity is keeping pace with our collective capability.


The title of this piece states a hypothesis at full strength, and I hold it as a hypothesis. I chose the strong form because a softer version would be agreed with and then forgotten.


By futurism, I mean the habit of locating meaning in what comes next. I recognise it in myself. I have spent around four decades inside complex human systems, and the pattern I learned to look for there is the distance between what a system is able to do and what the people inside it are equipped to carry. While the attention is on the next platform or the next restructure, the consequences of the last one are landing on whoever happens to be standing in the present.


Scale that pattern up from an organisation to a species and a question appears that I have not been able to put down. Is our collective maturity keeping pace with our collective capability?


Two Trajectories


We tend to speak of human advancement as though it were a single trajectory. Progress, in that telling, is one line, and our tools and our judgement rise along it together. What if there are two lines, and they are moving apart?



Conceptual illustration of the hypothesis, not measured data.
Conceptual illustration of the hypothesis, not measured data.

The first line is capability: what we are able to build, reach, compute and alter. It compounds, because each tool becomes the means of making the next one. The second line is maturity, by which I mean our collective capacity to hold power with judgement and to restrain ourselves when restraint goes unrewarded.


Maturity does not appear to compound in the same way. Although each generation inherits the knowledge and institutions of those before it, it still has to develop the judgement required to apply them. Maturity cannot simply be transferred from one place to another the way a technological design can.


The space between those two lines is what I call the maturity gap. I suspect it is where our greatest collective vulnerability resides, partly because a gap of this kind is hard to see from the capability side, where everything that gets counted is going up.


The drawing has no scale because we have no universally accepted measure of collective maturity, and I am wary of reducing something so complex to a single number.


Five Contradictions


The gap shows itself as a set of contradictions, each of them ordinary enough that we have stopped noticing it.


  • We are developing artificial intelligence while struggling to manage our own emotional intelligence.

  • We are exploring the colonisation of other planets while struggling to coexist sustainably on our own.

  • We have unprecedented access to knowledge without a corresponding capacity for discernment.

  • We have built extraordinary communication technologies while struggling to understand one another.

  • We are engineering increasingly autonomous systems while questioning how much autonomy humans themselves retain.


None of these is an indictment of progress, and I would not hand back the technologies on that list. What the contradictions do is put pressure on the word itself. In each pair the first half is counted as progress and the second half is treated as a private matter, or as somebody else’s department. We are working with a definition of progress that registers only one of the two lines.


The fifth contradiction is the one I return to most. Decisions are being handed to systems that act without us, while a growing share of human attention is steered by systems built to hold it. The question of machine autonomy and the question of human autonomy are being settled at the same time, by many of the same technologies, and they receive very different amounts of scrutiny.


Four Propositions


I build the exploration on four propositions.


  1. Capability determines what is possible.

  2. Maturity determines what is appropriate.

  3. Discipline enables us to navigate the relationship between the two.

  4. Wisdom allows us to recognise when possibility should remain possibility.


The first two describe the lines, and the remaining two describe what an organisation or a society does about the distance between them. Discipline is the one the title accuses us of neglecting.


The word has a poor reputation, mostly because it arrives carrying punishment. Its Latin origins lie in teaching and learning, and it is in that spirit of cultivated practice that I am using it: the repeated, unglamorous work of deciding how a thing will be governed before it is released, and of staying with a consequence long enough to understand it. Most of it is maintenance, which goes some way to explaining why futurism has so little use for it. Maintenance has no launch date.


There is a known difficulty here, set out by David Collingridge in The Social Control of Technology in 1980. Early in the life of a technology it is easy to change and its consequences are hard to foresee. By the time the consequences are clear, the technology is embedded and change has become slow and expensive. I read that dilemma as an argument for discipline as a standing capacity. If the window for easy correction closes before we know what needs correcting, the ability to govern has to exist before the thing it governs arrives.


Wisdom is the proposition I find hardest to defend, and I keep it anyway. It says that some things which can be done are better left as possibilities. Our culture has very little vocabulary for that choice, and a capability left unused tends to be read as a failure of nerve. There is precedent all the same. In 1974 a group of leading molecular biologists called for a voluntary pause on certain recombinant DNA experiments, and the Asilomar conference the following year recommended the safeguards under which the work could resume. The pause was temporary and it was contested, and it remains evidence that a field can look at what it is able to do and decide to wait.


I do not believe any of this amounts to an argument against technology. A species that stopped building would have a different problem. What I am questioning is the assumption that the second line will take care of itself provided the first climbs fast enough.


Whether the gap can be closed, or only managed, I do not know. It may be that maturity can be designed for, the way load is designed for in a structure, and that we have simply never treated it as a design problem. The other possibility is that it grows only through consequence, a harder thought and one I have not finished with.


We have become very good at asking what we are capable of becoming.


Whether we are becoming capable of responsibly managing what we create is a separate question, and I do not think the first one answers it.


References

Collingridge, D. (1980). The Social Control of Technology. Frances Pinter, London.

Berg, P., et al. (1974). Potential biohazards of recombinant DNA molecules. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 71(7), 2593–2594. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.71.7.2593

Berg, P., et al. (1975). Summary statement of the Asilomar conference on recombinant DNA molecules. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 72(6), 1981–1984. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.72.6.1981


About SJ Greaves


SJ Greaves is a twice-exceptional (autistic and gifted) thinker, writer, strategist and artist whose work explores the intersections of human behaviour, complex systems, technology and collective evolution.


Drawing on four decades of experience navigating complex human systems, SJ questions established narratives, explores overlooked patterns and interrogates the assumptions that shape how we live, work and evolve.


Through Little Red Notebook, SJ creates space for intellectual curiosity, unconventional thinking and the exploration of possibilities beyond conventional boundaries.


Their work is driven not by the pursuit of definitive answers, but by a curiosity about the questions we have yet to ask.

Comments


  • Youtube

©2025 by Little Red Notebook

​

Acknowledgement of Country

At Little Red Notebook, we acknowledge the Traditional Custodians of the lands on which we live, create, and work.

 

We pay deep respect to Elders past and present, and extend that respect to all First Nations peoples across Australia.

​

We recognise that the stories, systems, and wisdom held within Country have long guided innovation, community, and care. We honour these enduring ways of knowing, being, and leading.

​

Little Red Notebook commits to walking in partnership, with humility, reciprocity, and bold respect, as we build new ways of working that embrace truth, complexity, and shared futures.

bottom of page